tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-24761391.post8191212881775894415..comments2023-10-26T22:06:11.166+11:00Comments on Metamagician3000: Back from Singularity Summit AURussell Blackfordhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/12431324430596809958noreply@blogger.comBlogger8125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-24761391.post-23545476689895004752010-09-15T07:10:52.096+10:002010-09-15T07:10:52.096+10:00Umm, I'd fear the torture for the exact same r...Umm, I'd fear the torture for the exact same reason I'd be worried if someone said, "Tomorrow after you wake up we're going to torture you."<br /><br />This is because I still don't see how the discontinuity of consciousness involved in uploading is any different from the discontinuity of consciousness involved in falling asleep and waking up.<br /><br />Are there any thought experiments clearing that up?<br /><br />-Dan L.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-24761391.post-58670444519871126782010-09-14T22:18:52.916+10:002010-09-14T22:18:52.916+10:00Thanks for speaking - it was really interesting.Thanks for speaking - it was really interesting.Joe Hannanoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-24761391.post-23864612719331146402010-09-14T14:47:07.231+10:002010-09-14T14:47:07.231+10:00In the persons A, B, and C question: A doesn't...In the persons A, B, and C question: A doesn't fear the torture, undergoes cloning, and receives no torture. But B, who has the same lack of fear as A, DOES receive torture! B's entire recollection of the events is consistent only with transference, so B should rightfully expect to transfer into C when cloned once more. B, then, would fear torture, but not be tortured; and also C would fear torture and then BE tortured. The critical point is their expectations are shared because the expectation is precloning - but their experiences are different, because that is postcloning.that qualia guynoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-24761391.post-61689411972109433382010-09-14T10:22:32.465+10:002010-09-14T10:22:32.465+10:00Lev, you're very welcome to submit material to...Lev, you're very welcome to submit material to JET. Just make sure you have a look at our site and follow the submission guidelines.Russell Blackfordhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12431324430596809958noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-24761391.post-33179221806438757612010-09-14T10:16:45.770+10:002010-09-14T10:16:45.770+10:00Adam, it's hard to get my head around all the ...Adam, it's hard to get my head around all the scenarios, but take the first case you mention. It's really not clear to me whether the person who exists prior to the severing of the corpus callosum should feel fear or not. If that's not clear, I don't see how it can be clear that the person who exists prior to the event can truly <i>look forward</i> to good things that will happen to the persons who (we're presuming) will exist after the corpus callosum is severed. It looks to me as if a lot of these ideas about what you can fear or look forward to become very problematic in these weird scenarios.<br /><br />The first scenario you describe with the A's, B's, and C's seems simple though. Assuming that all of these persons know which one they are (which they may not if the super-scientist tries to deceive them) I don't see why person B should fear (in the full sense) something that is going to happen to person C. I think this talk about what is part of your "identity" is unhelpful and could easily lead to question begging. Obviously the fusion scenario makes a difference, though again this is so weird that it's hard to know what to say.<br /><br />What we can say as a general observation, I think, is that it is often highly problematic to think that I can look forward to a certain experience had by someone psychologically like me who comes into existence as a result of uploading.Russell Blackfordhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12431324430596809958noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-24761391.post-87020449843574233782010-09-13T20:06:41.073+10:002010-09-13T20:06:41.073+10:00Hi Russell,
Great talk, it generated interesting a...Hi Russell,<br />Great talk, it generated interesting audience response...<br />I was left wondering: Take a scenario in which one's corpus callosum were cut, in such that two brain hemispheres were unaware of each others experience. If the right brain was informed that the left brain would be inflicted with horrific mental torture in the near future, would the right brain as a consequence be likely to experience fear? <br />Also consider that the right brain would also have long term memories of times before the corpus callosum was severed.<br /><br />As a separate addition to the above thought experiment, say the right brain knew that at some time in the future, the corpus callosum would be completely repaired and rejuvenated. Would the right brain as a consequence experience fear?<br /><br /><br />The other thought is this (which might be similar to James Newton-Thomas' idea): Consider that Person B is a clone of person A, and person C is a clone of Person B.<br />Person B's identity consists of all memories of Person A up to the time of cloning, plus the memory of the experience of being cloned (e.g. an awareness of the cloning process). Thus having the cloning process as part of it's identity.<br />If Person C were to be tortured in the near future, and Person B knew of it beforehand, would Person B likely experience fear? <br />(And as a separate joining scenario, if Person A knew that through some technological marvel, all the additional memories of Person B and C were to be later merged into person A in the after Person C's torture was complete, would Person A then experience fear for Person C's torture?)<br /><br /><br />Again, thank you so very much for spending the time and effort to present, which added great value to the Singularity Summit Australia 2010!<br /><br />Cheers, Adam A Fordspiral_shellhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/17378584752759768681noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-24761391.post-89455148515109663912010-09-13T16:19:05.317+10:002010-09-13T16:19:05.317+10:00I like reading your blog from time to time and of ...I like reading your blog from time to time and of course I consider myself a Trekkie who likes to consider the cool things that happen in science fiction. <br /><br />For some reason here, this upload thingy doesn't really make sense. <br /><br />Though, it does kinda remind me of someone's "Big Brain" discussion....<br /><br /><br />It leaves me wondering just how much navel gazing on these subjects is actually fruitful.mryananoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-24761391.post-3370766204012583852010-09-13T14:42:38.989+10:002010-09-13T14:42:38.989+10:00I really should have guessed that you and Jeremy k...I really should have guessed that you and Jeremy know each other - we go back quite a few decades ourselves.<br /><br />Sorry I missed your talk, but I already had another commitment on the Sunday. <br /><br />I am also interested in re-working my own presentation for JET....Lev Lafayettehttp://levlafayette.comnoreply@blogger.com